Verily, renunciation of obligatory action is not proper. Abandonment through delusion is declared to be of the nature of tamas.
Krishna directly challenges the notion that abandoning prescribed duties is spiritual. By connecting improper renunciation to tamas (ignorance), he establishes an important hierarchy of action, where how and why one acts becomes more important than whether one acts.
He who abandons action out of fear of bodily trouble because it is painful, performing rajasic relinquishment, does not obtain the reward of relinquishment.
This verse explores psychological motivations behind renunciation, warning against abandoning duties merely to avoid discomfort. True spirituality isn't about avoiding difficulty but transcending the duality of pleasure and pain through proper understanding of duty.
When obligatory action is performed only because it ought to be done, abandoning attachment and fruit, that relinquishment is regarded as sattvic.
The concept of sattvic relinquishment introduces the highest form of action—performed simply because it is right, without attachment to outcomes. This establishes the framework for selfless service (nishkama karma) that becomes the Gita's practical solution to action vs. inaction.
The relinquisher who is imbued with sattva, who is wise and whose doubts are cut asunder, does not hate disagreeable action, nor is he attached to agreeable action.
Krishna describes the psychological state of the sattvic relinquisher, who has transcended preferences and aversions. This balanced outlook, free from exaggerated attachment or aversion, characterizes the mind of one established in wisdom—the prerequisite for selfless action.
Verily, the embodied cannot completely relinquish actions. He who relinquishes the fruits of action is called a relinquisher.
This verse acknowledges human limitations while offering a practical solution. Rather than impossible total renunciation of action, Krishna provides the accessible path of renouncing attachment to results—making liberation possible while living in the world.
The threefold fruit of action - disagreeable, agreeable and mixed - accrues after death to those who do not practice relinquishment, but never to renouncers.
Here Krishna reveals the consequences of action across lifetimes, introducing karma's threefold fruition. This establishes why renunciation of results is essential for liberation, connecting immediate practice with ultimate spiritual consequences.
Learn from Me, O mighty-armed one, these five factors for the accomplishment of all actions, as declared in the Sankhya which is the end of all actions.
Krishna transitions to Sankhya philosophy's analysis of action, broadening his teaching beyond individual choice to the cosmic principles governing all activity. This analytical framework helps Arjuna understand action from an objective, metaphysical perspective.